Site icon MageeNews.com

Voters didn’t reject conservatism. They rejected tariffs.

Please note that this post contains affiliate links and any sales made through such links will reward MageeNews.com a small commission – at no extra cost to you.

Voters didn’t reject conservatism. They rejected tariffs.

So. Tariffs. Not so great, eh?

America has just given the world a master class as to why tariffs are a very bad idea, both economically and politically.

Two years ago, Donald Trump was reelected, carrying every one of the swing states. He beat Kamala Harris, standing in for an administration widely blamed for soaring inflation and the rising cost of gas and groceries.

Yet within weeks of taking office, Trump slapped tariffs on Canada, Mexico and China, then on steel, aluminum and cars. On “Liberation Day” in April 2025, he hit almost every country, friend and foe alike, with tariffs of 10 to 50 per cent.

Tariffs, some told us at the time, were all about taking on China. In which case, why, for heaven’s sake, were they applied on imports from Canada?

Of course, it was neither Canadians nor the Chinese that paid the tariffs. It was the American consumer. The National Taxpayers Union estimated a few months back that tariffs are costing US consumers around $200 billion a year. A basket of everyday back-to-school supplies is now $147 more expensive than before due to tariffs.

We know beyond doubt that tariffs were the key issue in the midterm election because the exit polls tell us so. Most voters said tariffs had hurt the economy. According to an NBC exit poll, about two thirds said the President’s policies had made it worse.

“But what about the Iran war?” some will ask. “Surely that played a part?”

It did, but it doesn’t let tariffs off the hook. It made the damage worse. Launched with little thought for the consequences, the war choked off oil shipments from the Gulf for months. Gas prices soared, and so did the cost of essentials such as fertilizer. Voters already squeezed by tariffs were squeezed again.

No state shows more vividly the part tariffs played in the Republicans’ midterm disaster than our own. Mississippi has just gone and elected a Democrat to the Senate for the first time since 1982.

The defeated incumbent, Cindy Hyde-Smith, was an unequivocal champion of tariffs — at least initially. “I think that it’s a really good tool,” she once said. “The president knows how to use that tool.”

Her victorious opponent, Scott Colom, was anti-tariff — consistently, repeatedly and relentlessly. “The tariffs are a sales tax,” he told voters. “They’re a tax on everything.”

In Mississippi, the Democrat ran as a free trader — and won.

Most Americans — in this state and beyond — have worked out that tariffs make them poorer. If you still doubt it, stand in Kroger and admire one of those $20 bags of ground coffee. When I moved here six years ago, they cost around $11.

In the summer of 2025, Washington slapped a 50 percent tariff on Brazilian coffee. Who was it meant to protect? Mississippi has no coffee farmers. Apart from a handful of growers in Hawaii, neither does America. A little over three months later, the White House quietly dropped the tariff on coffee — which was as good as admitting that the tariff was being paid by ordinary American households.

Much of the damage done by tariffs could not so easily be undone. Mississippi’s soybean crop is worth around $1.6 billion a year, and almost all of it is sold abroad — at one time mostly to China.

When tariffs triggered a trade war, Beijing stopped buying American soybeans. It placed no orders for much of last year. Guess who filled the gap? Brazil. A market Mississippi farmers had spent decades building was handed to their biggest competitor. Even after a trade deal, China’s purchases are about half what they were.

It gets worse. That same summer, Washington put a 50 percent tariff on Brazilian beef, just as American beef prices were already soaring. The White House dropped that too within months — again an admission that it was American households paying. But the damage was done.

A pound of ground beef cost $6.76 last month. Five years ago, it was $4.72.

“Hold on!” I hear you wondering, “Why not feed our own soybeans to our own cattle, and stop relying on foreigners for either?”

Some 250 years ago, Adam Smith showed that nations grow rich by buying from others what those others make more cheaply. If that lesson has not yet reached policymakers, let me put it more bluntly.

Try telling a Mississippi mom at the checkout, worried whether she has enough on her card, that self-sufficiency is in the interests of her family, as you make her pay more for less. You might as well be telling her to go “pick another protein.”

To be fair to Cindy Hyde-Smith, she never actually said “pick another protein”, and in my view a fair amount of the campaign coverage was unfair to her.

When farmers complained about the cost of fertilizer, she went to the White House and fixed it by having the tariffs on it lifted. The same order also scrapped tariffs on beef and coffee.

But if tariffs are bad for Mississippi farmers when they buy fertilizer, why are they good for anyone else? It was another quiet admission of who pays — clear for anyone with eyes to see, long before the election disaster earlier this month.

And it really was a disaster for the Republican Party. Texas has elected its first Democratic governor since 1990. Georgia elected Democrats to every statewide office. Kansas has sent a Democrat to the Senate for the first time in 94 years.

Democrats now hold at least 55 seats in the Senate. They are still short of the two thirds needed to override a presidential veto. Even so, I suspect that for the next two years it will often feel as if the Democrats are in power but not in office, while the Republicans are in office but not in power.

My greater fear, however, is that people will draw the wrong lessons.

Already there is pressure on the President to back off enforcing the law on illegal immigration. A robust approach on immigration is the glue that has held the conservative coalition together. Go soft on that, and American conservatives will end up in as sorry a state as British ones.

I fear something similar regarding data centers. Republicans did badly despite being on the right side of that argument, not because of it. If the party now reads the result as a verdict against growth, it will throw away the one thing that can bring bills down — more investment, more jobs and more energy.

Voters did not reject conservatism. They rejected a tariff policy that made them poorer. The answer to that is not less free enterprise. It is more.

Perhaps there is one silver lining. If Texas and Georgia now choose to be governed like California, Mississippi has a chance to double down on a pro-growth agenda. Washington sets tariffs. Jackson can do a whole raft of things that make us more competitive. Get rid of the income tax. Say yes to new investment. Go all in on affordable energy.

States that turn their backs on growth lose. Let’s make sure Mississippi is the one that gains.

Douglas Carswell is president and CEO of the Mississippi Center for Public Policy.

 

MageeNews.com is the online news source for Simpson and surrounding counties as well as the State of Mississippi.

Exit mobile version